An excerpt from the first Jesse Donovan mystery That She Is Made of Truth which you really should read.
I do believe her though I know she lies
— William Shakespeare
— Jesse Donovan
After their 5th anniversary, he smiled less and stopped laughing.
After their 6th anniversary, he started talking less.
After their 7th anniversary, he started drinking.
After their 8th anniversary, he started coming home with lipstick on his collar and perfume that wasn’t hers lingering as he stomped through the living room and up to bed.
On their 9th anniversary, at what had become an annual torture session, he swore at their server and stormed from the restaurant.
She threw a handful of $20 bills on the table and ran after him.