Our Story

Sue's Story

Our story begins thirty years ago. We met when my family moved to Imperial Beach where Joel’s family lived. I was just nine and Joel was thirteen. His sister and I became best of friends. When I started having crushes as a teenager on every boy in sight, Joel was one of those boys, but I never told anyone. So he grew up and got married while I was still just a girl of sixteen. How disappointed I was! But what could I do? So I grew up and got married two days out of high school. I was much too young and had never stopped having feelings for Joel.

Joel and his family were close friends with me and my family. Over the next twenty years our children were as close as cousins. In fact, I babysat his oldest son when he was a baby and was at the birth of his youngest in Texas. Our families remained close and the feelings I had for Joel never went away.

Eight years ago Joel was working in an office and needed someone to help out with various tasks. So he hired me. And that’s where the story really begins. After working together every day for months, we became extremely close, though we did not reveal to each other the feelings we had for one another. Then in August of 1995 the company we worked for sent several people in the company along with their spouses to San Francisco for a weekend trip. So Joel and I went along with our spouses. And that’s when I really fell in love with Joel. When we returned home after that weekend, I knew I was head over heels in love. Though I never told Joel how I felt, it was obvious. Yet I believed we both needed to work hard to make our marriages work. So after months of struggling with my feelings, I quit that job to move on and hoped we both could make our marriages work.

For the next seven years we barely spoke and rarely saw one another. Perhaps once or twice a year at an event both our families would attend. We might say hi to each other, but that was about it. After eight years we both thought that we had a handle on our emotions and that they would never present a problem. However, after his marriage was obviously coming to an end, he came to stay with my family for a while. Neither of us thought our living under the same roof for any length of time would present a challenge. How wrong we were!

It became obvious after a few weeks that we were madly in love with one another and that all the feelings we had previously for one another were still strong. I confessed to Joel that I had feelings at one time for another person, but did not indicate it was him. He thought it was someone else. One night he confessed to me, “I wish it was me.” The next morning I knew I could no longer hold back. I had to let him know how I had always felt. So I wrote a letter confessing my true feelings. We thought even then we could have these feelings yet keep them under control. But after 20 years in an emotionally sterile marriage where I never felt ‘in love’, I could no longer control the immense feelings I had for Joel. I knew the only right choice was to send Joel away, never to see him again. I just couldn’t do it. I wanted Joel to ask me to go away with him.

One weekend in May 2003 Joel and my family took a trip to Arizona and I thought this would be the last time I would get to spend anytime with him and that after this he would leave my life for good. We were all on the way back to the home of the family we were spending the weekend with and stopped at a rest stop. Joel told me he needed to speak with me privately later when we got back to where we were staying. I felt then that Joel was going to tell me he was leaving and ask me if I would go with him.

And that’s where our stories merge.

Joel's Story

Sue and I have known each other nearly all our lives. For the first 20 years, though, she was mostly 'my little sister's friend.' Once she was married, our families spent a lot of time together until my family moved to Texas for seven years.

When we returned to California, things were never the same with my marriage. Even if I could point to exactly what went wrong, I can't go back and fix it, though for years, I tried. After seven years of separation, living in the same house, things reached a peak, and I finally moved out. The first people I turned to for help were my lifelong friends, which turned out to be a two-edged sword. Sue and I had worked together shortly after my return from Texas, and though we never stated it explicitly, it was clear we had feelings for each other. But during those difficult seven years, we rarely saw each other or spoke; we were both genuinely trying to save our marriages. I foolishly assumed that after so much time our feelings would be under control.

Shortly after moving into the spare room at their house, it was obvious that nothing had changed. Whether it was the loneliness of both our marriages or our remarkable compatibility, in no time it was clear that, if either of our marriages were going to stand a chance, I needed to leave and never see Sue again. It was heartbreaking to think of giving up someone who deeply cared for me, but we were both raised with powerful moral values and couldn't even consider any other options; at least, at the time.

I was also getting lots of peer pressure to return to my wife. Everyone seemed to think that if I'd just move back home, everything would sort of work itself out. I tried talking to my wife about some of the critical issues that were driving us apart, and she wasn't willing to budge. She made it clear that, if I came back, nothing was going to change, and she thought that was the right thing.

I'd lost my job a month before, so I had a bit of free time while I tried to rebuild my web design business. I had planned a weekend visiting friends in Phoenix, expecting to repeat my Oak Creek/Sedona/Jerome/Prescott circuit. Sue's family, ready for a vacation, decided to come along to visit with our mutual friends and make the Oak Creek circuit with me.

It was a great trip, except for the looming spectre of the intense pressure when I returned to San Diego. I did my best to enjoy myself, but every step of the way I was frustrated and irritated at Sue's husband's lack of respect for her; his apparent lack of concern. For months I'd been bothered by the sterility in their relationship. I knew Sue was a passionate person with strong feelings, but he just didn't seem to notice. It was doubly difficult to think of returning to the pain of my own marriage, and abandoning Sue to the desolation of her own.

Sunday evening, driving back to Phoenix from our Oak Creek trip, I was miserable. I knew that in the morning we were leaving to go back to San Diego; back to the likelihood of returning to my marriage. Despite my strong love for my kids, I just couldn't face it. Looking back, I'm not sure which is worse, the pain of my marriage or the pain of not seeing my children. But, at the time, I thought my kids would understand that their Mom and I just couldn't live together any more. I decided to leave; to just get on a plane and see where it took me.

This is where the two stories become one.


When we got back to Phoenix, nearly everyone went off to bed as soon as possible. Sue and her son and I stayed up, building a puzzle. At 3 a.m. we finished it, and he went off to bed. I started to tell Sue that I just couldn't go back, and that I was leaving, and before I realized what I was saying, I'd asked her to go with me.

In the same breath I begged her to say no. I didn't want her family broken up like mine; I didn't want to throw away a lifetime of moral values, to offend the sensibilities of all our friends and family, to take a step which I knew could never be undone. I knew it would be hard to leave alone, but I knew it was for the best.

Sue didn't answer directly. Instead, she started talking about her marriage, her kids, her job; all the things that made up her life. I was relieved; it clearly sounded like she was explaining why she was going to stay.

Instead, she said, "So, I've been waiting all night for you to ask me." We sat, stunned, for I don't know how long.

We were both already packed for the drive the next morning. Well, that morning; by now it was 4 a.m. We simply picked up our bags, Sue wrote a note for her daughter (who, if it wouldn't have caused her even more emotional damage, we would have taken with us) and we walked out, got a cab, and went to the airport.

Our goal was San Francisco, the place where we now realized we'd fallen in love eight years ago. Last minute flights were frightfully expensive, but a rental car was only $25 a day. We both love driving, and figured this would give us plenty of time to think and talk on the way. We had more time than we thought possible, as it turns out.

Instead of taking the 'sure thing' across from Phoenix to Los Angeles, then heading north, we set a precedent for our driving patterns over the time we've been together and headed off on smallish state highways, planning on turning left at Las Vegas and heading right across Yosemite to San Francisco. Sure, the road through Yosemite said 'Closed in Winter' but it was the last weekend of May, so I wasn't worried.

We arrived in Las Vegas in the heat of the early afternoon hoping that we could catch a flight from Las Vegas and finish the trip by air. The Las Vegas airport apparently starts at one side of the city and ends at the other side of the city. We parked the car in the rental return lot, let them know we were not sure if we were done with the car yet, and started the trek across the airport to check on flights to San Francisco. When we arrived, it turned out flights from Las Vegas to San Francisco are only marginally cheaper than flights from Phoenix to San Francisco. So we trudged back across the airport, got in our rental car, and headed down the road once again.

By now, after 36 hours without sleep, we both were just the tiniest bit groggy. Sue took over driving for a bit and I somehow managed to doze off. I woke up as my head bounced off the window to look over and see Sue sitting cross legged, weaving down the mountain road with cruise control on. Feeling it was a bit early in our new relationship to complain about her driving techniques, I merely voiced the fact that I’d never used cruise control on mountain roads before.

I remember thinking that if things started to feel out of control I’d stop using cruise control. And just about then I knew it was time and that things were just about out of control.

Moments later I decided that if our relationship was going to get much older I should speak up as we dove into a curve in a little valley. Apparently Sue felt same way as she jammed on the brakes almost too late. I think we put about 20,000 miles on the tires in the next 100 yards and just about as many miles on my heart. Fortunately we slid to a grinding halt against the side of the mountain to the left and not in the ravine to the right or an oncoming car (there weren't any.) We decided not to use cruise control in the mountains anymore.

My adrenaline rushed caused me to feel it was a lot more fun than scary. But I’d never want to do that again.

Crossing the state line into California, we found a small, small town where everything was closed except a convenience store which didn’t have anything appealing for dinner. We asked the proprietor where the nearest restaurant was and he said we'd just passed it one block back. I said "They were closed." He said, "No, they're open." We drove back and sure enough the ramshackle, unlit, once-a-gas-station building was a restaurant, and was open. I don’t remember what we ate but we enjoyed it.

(I believe Joel had chili.)

(So, what did you have?)

I had been calculating our intended progress based on freeway speeds which these tiny, winding highways wouldn't permit. We arrived at the highway crossing Yosemite shortly after dark.

It was closed.

We drove back up the road to a gas station and asked about it. Everyone in the gas station said, “Oh yeah, big snow late April. It will be closed through June.” Not wanting to wait through June, we asked the locals about the shortest route to San Francisco. They unanimously suggested that from Phoenix we should have driven 10 to Los Angeles and north on Interstate 5. I said thanks and asked if there was a way to get there from here. They directed us up 395 (which ultimately goes all the way to Lake Tahoe and beyond) and across 50 through Sacramento to San Francisco. But rather than wasting an extra hour driving all the way up 395 to 50, they said to ' one hour up 395, take 89, then 88 across to 50 and it would save more than an hour and from there it’s two or three hours to San Francisco.'

So thinking we had only four hours to go and we’d be in our hotel room in San Francisco around midnight, we headed up 395, clinging to the edge of the mountain, with gorgeous scenery to our right in the moonlight and mountainsides straight up on our left. We came to 89 exactly where it was supposed to be and few short minutes down this microscopic winding road we came to 88 and headed down a smaller, even more winding road on the other side of the mountain tops. With mountains to our right and a ravine to our left, we wound down 88 for what should have been a 10 mile drive to Interstate 50 and an easy three hour cruise to San Francisco. But even at those speeds, ten miles shouldn’t have taken half an hour. We finally dug out the map and couldn’t find where we were. There didn’t seem to be any road marks, we hadn’t passed any towns or other roads, and just kept driving till we found something, a small town, not on our map. So we kept going. An hour later we came to a small town and took out the road map and retraced our route on the map to discover we should never have left 89 in the first place. It would have taken us straight to 50 and we’d be cruising at freeway speeds by now.

Realizing too late that it no longer made sense to find a way to the interstate, we looked at the map and decided to continue down the beautiful mountain road to somewhere south of San Francisco and head north into the city. This was a mistake. By now it was past midnight, my eyes felt like sandpaper and we were driving 15 miles an hour in the center of this tiny, weaving road because we didn’t want to bounce off the mountain or bounce off the treetops ten feet from the edge of the road. We wound and wound and wound and wound and eventually wound up somewhere in Lodi, which if you consult a map, makes no sense whatsoever.

As I headed for the offramp in Lodi, nearly 40 hours after my last real sleep, the sloping black of the offramp suddenly became a sheer white climb. I was confused and then I was surprised and then I realized I had fallen asleep for an instant and I was heading for a concrete block wall. Fortunately this all happened a bit faster than it takes to tell it and we went up the offramp, not up a block wall.

We really shouldn’t have kept pushing ourselves. But I, for one, just wanted to get where we intended, the sooner the better.

At least someone in Lodi knew how to get to San Francisco without winding through mountains. We ultimately reached our hotel in San Francisco on Knob Hill at five in the morning, only 25 hours after leaving Phoenix.

After a week in San Francisco, during which Sue’s daughter joined us, we realized that San Francisco was not too expensive for our budget, it was way too expensive for our budget. Thinking I knew a bit about the Sacramento area, we decided to head inland to the center of California’s central valley. Glancing at the map in late afternoon I noticed a suburb on the north side of Sacramento called Roseville. Knowing that Sue has an absolute passion for roses, I secretly decided to see if we could find a place to live, at least temporarily, in Roseville. After an hour or so Sue consulted the map to see how far we had to go and said "See that, Roseville? I want to live there." We spent one night in a hotel in Sacramento and the next day began apartment shopping. By that night were sleeping in the apartment we still live in today.